Opening summary
Donald Trump’s proposal for a US takeover of Gaza has been met with anger and blunt rejection from regional allies, delight from Israel’s far right and a warning against “ethnic cleansing” from the head of the UN.
The secretary general, António Guterres, told a UN meeting on Wednesday that “it is essential to avoid any form of ethnic cleansing” after the US president said he wanted to “own” Gaza and resettle its Palestinian residents elsewhere.
Both regional critics and supporters recognised that Trump’s vision for a “Riviera for the Middle East” would insert the US directly into the heart of one of the most volatile, long-running conflicts in the world.
Trump officials, meanwhile, appeared intent to walk back his position. Addressing the president’s comments on Wednesday, the White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt said it “does not mean boots on the ground in Gaza” after Trump left a US military presence an open question on Tuesday. The secretary of state, Marco Rubio, said the Trump plan was not meant as a “hostile move”, but rather a generous gesture aimed at rebuilding.
Saudi Arabia was among the first countries to reject Trump’s project to reimagine Gaza as a real-estate prospect, and perhaps the most consequential. Riyadh was quick to announce its “unequivocal rejection” of any attempt to displace Palestinians from their land.
In other developments:
-
Defence secretary Pete Hegseth said the Pentagon was prepared to look at “all options” when it comes to Gaza. Hegseth made the comments on Wednesday before meeting with Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu.
-
Donald Trump’s Middle East envoy, Steve Witkoff, reportedly said the US president does not want to put any American troops into Gaza. “Witkoff said that the president doesn’t want to put any troops into Gaza, and that he doesn’t want to spend any US money on Gaza,” the Republican senator for Missouri, Josh Hawley, said, according to the Washington Post.
-
Peace through strength is a concept Israel shares with the United States, Netanyahu said. “The only way to get peace, and enduring peace, is by being very, very strong,” he said, according to a readout of the meeting. “And with our alliance and your support, including the decision … of supplying Israel the much-needed tools for our defense, we are a lot stronger than we’ve ever been.”
-
The UN said forcible deportation of people from occupied territory is “strictly prohibited” under international law, while Human Rights Watch said the policy would be a “moral abomination”. Amnesty International condemned Donald Trump’s comments as “inflammatory, outrageous and shameful”. International law experts said it could amount to a war crime or crime against humanity.
-
Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas said Gaza was “an integral part of the State of Palestine” and that “we will not allow the rights of our people … to be infringed on”.
-
The estimated death toll in Gaza since the start of Israeli operations in the territory after the 7 October attacks reached 47,552, according to the Palestinian ministry of health on Wednesday.
Key events
Even by his own wild standards, Donald Trump shocked the world on Tuesday evening by suggesting the US should take over the Gaza Strip, displace millions of Palestinians and turn the territory into the ‘Riviera of the Middle East’.
It was a plan casually announced by the US president and immediately denounced around the world. In particular, the idea that the Palestinians of Gaza should be resettled in neighbouring Arab countries seems to amount to a form of ethnic cleansing.
As the Guardian’s diplomatic editor, Patrick Wintour, explains, it was just the latest move by Trump in a week that has rattled US allies and adversaries alike. The Trump administration has threatened trade wars with the US’s biggest trading partners. At the same time, the president has in effect frozen USAid, the largest aid organisation in the world.
As Helen Pidd hears, it is a new age of chaos that governments around the world seem barely prepared for. You can listen to the podcast episode here:
West Bank healthcare system in ‘perpetual emergency’ – report
The healthcare system in the occupied West Bank has been in “a state of perpetual emergency” since October 2023, Doctors Without Borders said in a new report published on Thursday.
“A dramatic escalation in violence, marked by prolonged Israeli military incursions and stricter movement restrictions … have severely hindered access to essential services, particularly healthcare, exacerbating already dire living conditions for many Palestinians,” it said, reports Agence France-Presse (AFP).
Violence in the region soared after Hamas’s unprecedented attack on Israel in October 2023, which triggered a massive retaliation by Israel that has levelled much of Gaza.
“Since October 7, 2023, the West Bank has seen a dramatic escalation in violence, marked by prolonged Israeli military incursions and stricter movement restrictions,” it said.
The report examined “the attacks and the obstructions of healthcare in a context of, what has been described by the ICJ (international criminal court) as segregation and apartheid” and revealed “a pattern of systematic interference by Israeli forces and settlers in emergency healthcare delivery”.
Malaysia says ’strongly opposes’ any plan to forcibly resettle Palestinians
Malaysia said on Thursday it “strongly opposes” any plan to forcibly resettle Palestinians from Gaza, Reuters reports.
Muslim-majority Malaysia has no diplomatic relations with Israel and many in the south-east Asian country support the Palestinians.
“Malaysia strongly opposes any proposal that could lead to the forced displacement or movement of Palestinians from their homeland,” the foreign ministry said in a statement. It said:
Such inhumane actions constitute ethnic cleansing and are clear violations of international law and multiple UN resolutions.”
Malaysian prime minister Anwar Ibrahim has been vocal in opposing Israel’s war against Hamas. Anwar has said that Malaysia maintains good relations with the political wing of Hamas but has no connections with its military wing.
His government has channelled donations and humanitarian aid amounting to $10.19m to the Palestinian people in Gaza since the war erupted.
Iran rejects ‘shocking’ Trump plan
Iran’s foreign ministry rejected Thursday what it called a “shocking” plan laid out by US President Donald Trump to take over Gaza and “forcibly displace” Palestinians from the coastal territory, AFP reports.
“The plan to clear Gaza and forcibly displace the Palestinian people to neighbouring countries is considered a continuation of the Zionist regime’s (Israel) targeted plan to completely annihilate the Palestinian nation, and is categorically rejected and condemned,” said foreign ministry spokesperson Esmaeil Baqaei.
Trump on Tuesday declared “the US will take over the Gaza Strip and we will do a job with it, too. We’ll own it”.
Speaking alongside Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu, Trump talked about “permanently” moving Palestinians out of Gaza.
The plan sparked uproar from Arab governments and world leaders, with the United Nations warning against “ethnic cleansing” in the Palestinian territory.
Baqaei described Trump’s plan as “an unprecedented attack on the fundamental principles and foundations of international law and the United Nations Charter.”
In Gaza, Donald Trump’s plan for the United States to take over the territory was met with anger and disbelief by Palestinians sheltering in the ruins of their houses, or crammed into makeshift camps.
They know better than anyone the terrible impact of 15 months of Israeli attacks that have reduced so much of Gaza to rubble.
Abu Firas, 52, lives in a tent on the coast that Trump claims he will remake into the “Riviera of the Middle East”. His home in eastern Khan Younis has been destroyed, and he lost 80 relatives.
He wants help rebuilding, not a ticket out of the place he loves. “We would rather die here than leave this land,” he told the Guardian. “No amount of money in the world can replace your homeland.”
Israeli defence minister orders army to prepare for Gaza residents’ departure – reports
Israeli defence minister Israel Katz has ordered the army on Thursday to prepare a plan to allow for the departure of Gaza residents from the strip, Israeli media reported, according to Reuters.
The instruction follows US President Donald Trump’s announcement that the US plans to take over Gaza and resettle the Palestinians living there, prompting widespread anger and rejection including from regional allies. Rights groups have condemned the suggestion as ethnic cleansing.
Katz is quoted as welcoming Trump’s “courageous plan, which could enable a wide swath of the population in Gaza to leave to various places around the world.”
“Gaza’s residents should be allowed the freedom to exit and emigrate, as is the practice anywhere around the world,” Katz said, according to The Times of Israel, adding that Trump’s plan could advance “rehabilitation plans in a demilitarized Gaza that poses no threat in the post-Hamas era, which will take many years.”
Netanyahu says Trump’s ‘remarkable idea’ should be pursued
Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu said on Wednesday that there was nothing wrong in Donald Trump’s idea of displacing Palestinians from Gaza after the US president’s proposal drew international criticism.
Rights groups have condemned as ethnic cleansing Trump’s suggestion the previous day that Palestinians in the territory should be permanently displaced, while also proposing a US takeover of Gaza.
In an interview with Fox News, Netanyahu did not explicitly talk about Trump’s idea of the US taking over the Gaza Strip but backed the idea of allowing people to leave if they wanted to.
“I mean, what’s wrong with that?” he said. “They can leave, they can then come back, they can relocate and come back. But you have to rebuild Gaza.”
Netanyahu said he did not believe Trump had suggested sending US troops to fight Hamas in Gaza or that Washington would finance rebuilding efforts.
“This is the first good idea that I’ve heard,” he added. “It’s a remarkable idea, and I think it should be really pursued, examined, pursued and done, because I think it will create a different future for everyone.”
Netanyahu also repeated his view that Trump is “the greatest friend that Israel has ever had in the White House”.
Opening summary
Donald Trump’s proposal for a US takeover of Gaza has been met with anger and blunt rejection from regional allies, delight from Israel’s far right and a warning against “ethnic cleansing” from the head of the UN.
The secretary general, António Guterres, told a UN meeting on Wednesday that “it is essential to avoid any form of ethnic cleansing” after the US president said he wanted to “own” Gaza and resettle its Palestinian residents elsewhere.
Both regional critics and supporters recognised that Trump’s vision for a “Riviera for the Middle East” would insert the US directly into the heart of one of the most volatile, long-running conflicts in the world.
Trump officials, meanwhile, appeared intent to walk back his position. Addressing the president’s comments on Wednesday, the White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt said it “does not mean boots on the ground in Gaza” after Trump left a US military presence an open question on Tuesday. The secretary of state, Marco Rubio, said the Trump plan was not meant as a “hostile move”, but rather a generous gesture aimed at rebuilding.
Saudi Arabia was among the first countries to reject Trump’s project to reimagine Gaza as a real-estate prospect, and perhaps the most consequential. Riyadh was quick to announce its “unequivocal rejection” of any attempt to displace Palestinians from their land.
In other developments:
-
Defence secretary Pete Hegseth said the Pentagon was prepared to look at “all options” when it comes to Gaza. Hegseth made the comments on Wednesday before meeting with Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu.
-
Donald Trump’s Middle East envoy, Steve Witkoff, reportedly said the US president does not want to put any American troops into Gaza. “Witkoff said that the president doesn’t want to put any troops into Gaza, and that he doesn’t want to spend any US money on Gaza,” the Republican senator for Missouri, Josh Hawley, said, according to the Washington Post.
-
Peace through strength is a concept Israel shares with the United States, Netanyahu said. “The only way to get peace, and enduring peace, is by being very, very strong,” he said, according to a readout of the meeting. “And with our alliance and your support, including the decision … of supplying Israel the much-needed tools for our defense, we are a lot stronger than we’ve ever been.”
-
The UN said forcible deportation of people from occupied territory is “strictly prohibited” under international law, while Human Rights Watch said the policy would be a “moral abomination”. Amnesty International condemned Donald Trump’s comments as “inflammatory, outrageous and shameful”. International law experts said it could amount to a war crime or crime against humanity.
-
Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas said Gaza was “an integral part of the State of Palestine” and that “we will not allow the rights of our people … to be infringed on”.
-
The estimated death toll in Gaza since the start of Israeli operations in the territory after the 7 October attacks reached 47,552, according to the Palestinian ministry of health on Wednesday.